Comparison of Radiosurgery Delivery Systems

The CyberKnife® is a form of radiosurgery, which means that instead of a scalpel, a the surgeon uses a single, high dose of radiation, which eliminates the diseased area safely and effectively. Only the tissue being treated receives a very high dose of radiation while the surrounding tissue remains unharmed. Radiosurgery is painless and bloodless and involves no risk of surgical complications such as infection, hemorrhage or leakage of cerebral spinal fluid.

Although the entire procedure takes several hours, the actual treatment itself takes just 15 minutes to one to three hours, depending on the size of the lesion(s) being treated. If there are multiple tumors are present or if the tumor spreads to another area, radiosurgery can be repeated. There is no risk of surgical complications such as infection, hemorrhage or leakage of cerebral spinal fluid.

Other radiosurgery delivery systems exist; however, not all radiosurgery is the same.  The following chart compares The CyberKnife® with the Gamma Knife and other Linac systems:

    CyberKnife® Gamma Knife® Other Linac Systems
(Elekta Synergy®, Novalis®,
Varian Trilogy®, TomoTherapy®)
 
Is it dedicated just to radiosurgery? YES YES NO
  What area of the body is treatable with radiosurgical precision? whole body Brain/Skull base
(minus extreme lateral)
Varies  
IMRT dosimetry Method YES NO YES
  IGRT Set-up Visualization YES NO YES  
NO NO YES
  Rigid Brain or Body Frame required for radiosurgical accuracy NO YES YES  
Capable of conformally and homogeneously treating an irregularly shaped tumor under 3.5cm YES NO YES
  Capable of fractionated radiosurgery to better preserve critical adjacent tissue YES NO YES  
Tracks patient-induced motion with radiosurgical precision (<1mm) YES NO  Varies by method and manufacturer
  Tracks spine motion with radiosurgical precision (<1mm) YES N/A NO  
Tracks organ induced target volume motion with radiosurgical precision (<1mm) YES N/A NO
  Tracks respiration induced organ motion with radiosurgical precision (<1.5mm) YES N/A NO  
Capable of real-time sub-millimeter translational and rotational beam adaptation to target volume motion YES N/A NO